Fixing the Royals.This morning, a re-worked version of my 'Five ideas for the Royals' piece appeared in the print edition of The Star, in the Daily Download space. I wanted to link to it and post here to serve as a forum to discuss some of these ideas. I'd really be interested in hearing feedback not only on those items, but also to hear any ideas of your own. I'm planning to do a Q&A with a Royals official soon and if anyone comes up with something intriguing, I'll throw it out there in the Q&A.
I would say the most "controversial" suggestion I made would be the platooning of Jose Guillen and Mike Jacobs. The Royals, I would guess, feel that the two, as a duo, are the team's best hopes for generating power in the lineup. I feel that the results dictate that the most production you're going to get from these two is in a job-sharing arrangement at DH. You are then able to improve the defense -- by a lot -- and offer better support to the pitching staff that is the bedrock of the team. However, Guillen's contract is excessive for a player that DHs against lefties. I say: Who cares?
I've already heard from someone that thinks Alex Gordon should not be given the starting job over Mark Teahen when he returns. Without elaborating right now, I'm wondering how many agree with this sentiment?
Finally, the item on flipping Coco Crisp and David DeJesus was based on a tip from mlb.com's Rustin Dodd. I don't pay too much attention to batting order issues because my basic philosophy is that the names in the lineup are everything -- the order you put them in is nearly meaningless. However, the splits Rustin pointed out are startling. Why is it that the number written next to a player's name in the lineup card would have such an effect on the player's performance? It baffles me.

1 & 2. I don't agree with the idea of platooning Guillen/Jacobs at DH and starting Maier regularly in RF. Yes, you gain a lot on D, but you also give up a LOT on O, and scoring runs has been a HUGE problem for this team. I do think that Guillen should DH and Jacobs should sit against lefties. There's no significant difference in Maier/Jacobs offensively against LHP, and we get a defensive upgrade.
3. Agreed. Though if this is the second best idea we have to improve the Royals... I bury my head in my hands :-(
4. Absolutely agreed. I remember how odd it was when we were doing this with Brian Anderson a few years ago... but it makes perfect sense with Greinke.
5. I'd like to... but at what cost? If they'll take Guillen off our hands, I'm all for it (even if it means paying his whole salary or something... its not my money) but I don't wanna give up much in our system.
6. Sounds like re-arranging the furniture on the Titanic, but heck, it can't hurt anything, can it?